Edward Lucas / Translation by iPress
The founder and director of the Baltic International Centre for Security and columnist Edward Lucas is convinced that Europe is once again under double pressure – Russian intimidation and American initiatives that could undermine the current security system. He believes that the problem is not in the lack of agreements or mechanisms, but in the fact that Russia has already violated its commitments, while the Trump administration shows no readiness to enforce them. In this context, Europe’s weakness and indecision only encourage external pressure, and frozen Russian assets might be one of the few real tools to strengthen Europe’s position and support Ukraine.
Concerns disrupt normal life – whether they come from the Trump administration or the Kremlin.
All over 70 bomb threat messages sent last week to airlines, editorial offices, and other addresses in Europe turned out to be false. But the damage was real: flights were redirected, buildings evacuated, plans disrupted, expenses incurred, and public trust weakened. The same happened with the recent, much larger, though metaphorical, threat to undermine the entire architecture of European security.
This threat did not come in an anonymous email, but through a post by Jared Kushner, Donald Trump’s son-in-law, on social media. He outlined five goals: “permanent consultations on security issues, reliable crisis communication, greater military transparency, mutual measures to reduce escalation risks, and a long-term framework for European security and stability.”
At first glance, this may sound quite innocent. But considering how this administration pressures allies and tries to appease adversaries, many interpreted it as a signal of preparing a deal between the East and West behind Europe’s back – likely also fueled by the Trump family’s business interests.
Europe does not lack a security architecture. Everything Kushner talks about is already contained in the Paris Charter of 1990, the Budapest Memorandum of 1994, the NATO-Russia Founding Act of 1997, and the Rome Declaration of 2002 (the latter, incidentally, was signed by none other than Putin).
It is Russia, driven by wounded pride, paranoia, and imperial interests, that has undermined these agreements. Every single one of them.
Therefore, the starting point for anyone genuinely interested in European security should be the demand that Russia fulfills the promises it has already made and respects the borders and sovereignty of other states. However, Kushner has not given any hint that the U.S. administration plans to pressure the Kremlin on these issues, or indeed on any others. Signs suggest rather the opposite. Last week, President Trump hosted the Russian envoy Kirill Dmitriev at the White House, but did not find time to speak with any representative from Ukraine. The American president stated that a “very large” deal could potentially cover “all of Europe.” Great. But these plans were not discussed with any European leader. Transatlantic trust has taken yet another severe blow.
European representatives heading to negotiations in Abu Dhabi on November 10 resemble people exiting a building following a bomb threat. It’s a prudent precautionary step. But no one expects anything to happen. If the agreement is vague, it will mean nothing. If it’s specific, Europeans will reject it. They will not twist Ukraine’s arm, forcing it into capitulation. Kyiv has already been offering an unlimited and unconditional ceasefire for 18 months. It is Russia that wants to continue the war.
Both real bomb threats and the geopolitical threat of a “blast” share a common root: Europe’s weakness. No one would send an email threat to the Kremlin or the White House about a bomb. Well-protected entities simply ignore such things. Instead, Europe is wide open to attacks—from threats and hoaxes to deadly state terrorism. So Russia intensifies the pressure. The implicit message is: “Give us Ukraine – and the pain will stop.”
Similarly, Russia, China, and the U.S. have a clear understanding of what they would like to do with Europe. However, Europe itself lacks a clear vision of its desired place in the world, and even more so, an understanding of the risks and sacrifices necessary to occupy it. If you’re not at the table, you’re on the menu.
This can be changed. At the European Union summit in Dublin on November 13, an agreement could be reached to transfer frozen Russian sovereign assets under the control of European institutions. Currently, most of them are held in Belgium, which is easy to pressure. Such a decision would safeguard these funds from Russian-American geopolitical banditry. It would create a financial instrument worth over 200 billion euros, which could be used to help Ukraine cope with the anticipated financial shortfall. And all this before May, when French voters are likely to detonate their big “bomb” under the European political system.
