“Delays are not an option”: Former Ambassador Valeriy Chaly on new challenges for Ukraine after the US elections

"Delays are not an option": Former Ambassador Valeriy Chaly on new challenges for Ukraine after the US elections

Olha Snitsarchuk / Radio Liberty

The defeat of Republicans and the victory of Democrats in the U.S. midterm elections: what does it mean for Ukraine and U.S. President Donald Trump? Former Ukrainian Ambassador to the U.S. Valeriy Chaly analyzed the unexpected election results on Radio Liberty’s program “Svoboda Live”.

  • Why didn’t the focus on MAGA work?
  • How can the new political reality in Washington affect arms supplies to Ukraine?
  • Why is the new Ambassador of Ukraine to the U.S. becoming a “kamikaze”?
  • How can Congress force Trump to change his stance on Putin?
  • What should Ukraine prepare for?
  • What might become a subject of negotiation?
  • And why might the final stage of negotiations come soon?

(The text version of the interview is shortened and edited for flow and clarity)

“Triumph of the Democrats”

– Mr. Valeriy, now the media, both American and global, describe what’s happening in the United States as a “blue wave”, “blue tsunami”, “triumph of the Democrats”. Your impressions of what happened.

– First of all, I would like to congratulate the American people because democratic elections took place. And, evidently, concerns about their disruption or technical disruption, cyberattacks – at least for now, I understand that all of this was neutralized. This is a very important result. So I congratulate this, it’s a good sign that credible elections can be held in America. That’s the first point.

Secondly, regarding the “Blue-nami”, as they call it, it’s unexpected, it really is. Because it’s one thing to simply predict the victory of the House of Representatives as has been done for a long time. Everyone has long agreed that the Democrats would have a majority. But now this majority is just tremendous, that’s first. Secondly, the Senate too – all the forecasts in the last week showed that the Democrats had an edge but with a lead of just two seats, one seat. I, by the way, thought more skeptically, that it would be.

– More skeptical about the Democrats?

– Maximum 51-49 in favor of the Democrats, or even 50-50. I’ll explain why. Because all the previous three elections showed that sociologists made mistakes, let’s say, underestimated the Republicans. This time they made a mistake again. Only now they underestimated the Democrats.

And the number of sociological services, it’s very good that it has increased, offering a broader assessment, but even now everyone will say that they knew the forecasts for sure, but those who calculated the statistics, not just sociology, were more accurate.

Secondly, and most importantly, why I thought there would be less, is because the Republicans set a task, not just thinking about it, but to challenge the election results in courts, first and foremost to have additional vote recounts. There were lawsuits filed in 20,000 cases in California, in Alaska. Donald Trump stated that he would not recognize the result in Alaska at all if Dan Sullivan, a Republican candidate, did not win.

According to preliminary data, from the results of the midterm elections to the US Congress, the Democrats are gaining a majority in both the Senate and the House of Representatives. According to the latest forecasts, the Democrats will have at least 54 out of 100 seats in the Senate and also a majority in the House of Representatives. Meanwhile, the Republicans suffered a defeat, including in several states where they had won for decades. US President Donald Trump said on election night that he recognized the results of the midterm elections and congratulated the Democrats.

That is, there were cyber attacks two weeks ago on the United States Electoral Commission. And these attacks were quite serious, originating from North Korea. Therefore, it was predicted that these attacks might be repeated now. In New York, there was a moment when they could not scan ballots, which turned out to be purely a technical internal issue. Thus, all American structures that counteract such interference in elections managed to do their job.

The Republican headquarters has not yet, as it is not visible now, boycotted the election results, which they talked about earlier. Because this sort of advantage, this absolute triumph, was unexpected for both Republicans and Democrats. If you look at American expert evaluations, such a plan of triumph was not anticipated.

Why? As mentioned, because Republicans were typically underestimated by sociology. Secondly, sociology has a margin of error. Another point, this is generally a historic transition. This has happened maybe twice over the last 100-plus years, when Democrats took both chambers in midterm elections. It happened under Eisenhower, if I’m not mistaken, in 1952.

Former US President Dwight Eisenhower (right) talks with Radio Free Europe Director Rodney Smith in front of a map showing the Radio Free Europe broadcasting area in the early 1960s

Eisenhower was supported, they simply had his support during complex situations, wars, while the economy and all other issues were an argument to give to the Democrats…

And the second time was Bush. A similar story occurred, where, against the backdrop of the Iraq operation, he lost both chambers in the midterm elections. By the way, they stopped the continuation of the operation further. But that’s the second scenario.

Overall, only six times in midterm elections has power shifted, that is, to a different party than the president’s.

So, this is a very unusual situation. And what happened in certain states is truly historic, because 1932, Kansas – they held…

– … for 98 years.

– Yes. And Texas also since the 90s – they held control there. So, yes, it’s a triumph and I think it was unexpected for the Democrats themselves.

– Texas for the first time in 38 years, Kansas, which you mentioned, for 94, not 98 as I said, and South Carolina for the first time in 28 years switched to the Democrats.

– By the way, the first Muslim senator in U.S. history. Interestingly, both Trump and DiVance, the vice president, opposed him. And now DiVance will have to swear him in as a senator.

A female governor, if these results are confirmed, of Texas. They expected that Musk would pour in nearly $200 million there in two weeks and were hoping to push their senator, but ended up losing even the governor. A woman, a Latina, a governor, not a senator. They missed that entirely. They focused all efforts against Talarico. As I said, Musk targeted Talarico, Talarico won. But Talarico was supported by the Bushes. The Bushes are significant in Texas.

So, Talarico – not just a Democrat, he came, if I remember correctly, from the Republicans. So it was clear that he would have a chance there. But they simply missed the governor’s race, they just didn’t work there. The Republicans didn’t have the strength in the last two weeks or the money to address these issues that arose.

And these firsts we will hear about more. Because there may still be a win for the first Native American woman, something that hasn’t happened in the Senate, a Native American.

I think there will be more women, which is good, in principle. The next Congress will probably be younger overall. But despite all this, we can say that the scenarios, especially regarding Ukraine, are not straightforward.

As for America – it’s a completely different issue here. It seems to me that Americans showed up in the largest turnout in a very long period. They came out as if for a plebiscite for or against Trump. And this was, of course, a huge mistake for the Republicans…

The consequences of this will be very interesting, because focusing on President Trump and MAGA candidates – it’s something that didn’t work this time, although it did before. And we see what happened, and that this is a correct signal.

“Hope for Refugees”

What has been happening and is happening in America with immigration policy is not only disliked by those who are the object of this policy. Because the fight against illegals has turned into something unclear. And the 250,000 Ukrainians there were also expecting results from this.

For them, this is a good signal that now there are opportunities for them to find some foothold, because they are in limbo; they are currently undocumented immigrants. 250,000 undocumented immigrants, meaning they were made such. It’s good that at least Ukrainians were left, because other countries were expelled. Only four countries remain under the status of “protected refugees,” well, under protected status TPS or UFU. And all other countries were simply told one day: “That’s it, your protection is over.” Therefore, hope has emerged for these people.

For many people who didn’t understand, well, they simply didn’t like or were irritated by Trump’s statements, his style, such people also left. And who gave this result? I think three categories: these are Latinos, who had many questions regarding migration policy. Second, those who were not MAGA, not the “Freedom Caucus,” but leaned more between neutral and political Republican candidates. They went to the elections this time and acted quite differently. And the neutral candidates Trump managed to attract earlier, they did not go this time. And this is evidence that a niche for a third candidate in presidential elections is emerging in America again.

– One of the winners already declared a phrase like “America has returned.” And you started talking a little about what prompted this choice? Does this prompting come more from Trump’s persona or from the circumstances, in your assessment?

– Persona. In America, there is indeed inflation, as it has always been. It’s not that high now. These are not critical things now. There’s no economic crisis in America that would make people react so negatively. But as President Donald Trump kept repeating that inflation is the best and we have the best prices for gasoline or diesel, and people saw something different, they probably just got tired of it.

– It’s unfulfilled promises.

– Yes. Plus Iran, which was absolutely unnecessary for the population. Here Trump acted confidently, he now said he would have done the same. That Iran is not about this, but about ensuring there is no nuclear weapon in the Middle East, although it is already there.

And there are big fears, and this story with Iran has not ended, it will continue.

So, in essence, what Donald Trump wanted played out, not only the Republicans as a whole, because Trump’s entourage controlled the headquarters: both financially and in managing processes. He himself, along with J.D. Vance, replaced candidates instead of the already confident Republican fighters, he changed them. And they did not pass.

By the way, Brian Fitzpatrick, who did a very good job in Pennsylvania, for example. He’s not just a member of the Caucus. There was also Fitzpatrick, a person with epaulettes, so to speak. And he knew the methods on how to do this work correctly. And not only him, but many Ukrainian diplomatic representatives collaborated with others. He will not be there. There will be no 11 senators, their terms simply ended. 10 of them were our supporters and very well-known supporters, that is, powerful ones. Like Nancy Pelosi, for example. I mean not only Republicans now…

The analysis will need more than just this number, although numbers are significant, they indeed create a new situation. The analysis must consider who entered, people with which programs. We didn’t talk about the programs at all. And this is also a consequence of the campaign set by the Republicans, Donald Trump. In fact, the Democrats adapted to it.

They were simply playing against Trump, and Trump created many conditions for him to be perceived negatively. That is, if you draw a conclusion, it’s more like the Republicans lost rather than the Democrats won, if we speak about the campaigns that took place. But the result is what we see.

“Friends of Ukraine”

– Among those who lost are people referred to as “great friends, allies of Ukraine,” including those you mentioned, Fitzpatrick, Lawler, Brsnahan, and Kari. The bipartisan support for Ukraine is not in doubt. But now I see rather ambiguous expectations. Some experts lean towards the idea that there will be a new wave of support, a kind of reincarnation of relations, while others, on the contrary, doubt – as you already discussed slightly – that Ukraine might face a new challenge.

– When we talk about bipartisan support, it’s not granted automatically. It’s work. And in these conditions, when Congress, not only the Democrats, spoke more decisively in support of Ukraine, but many things were practically blocked in the White House. So, I think it will be easier for them now since there were joint initiatives. Well, for instance, Graham’s law just passed regarding sanctions.

– By the way, his sister didn’t pass.

– Well, it’s clear why she didn’t pass. Because, again, she was an inexperienced candidate and Trump supported her. Thus, they lost this position. It didn’t happen only there; it also happened in several places where inexperienced MAGA representatives, relatively inexperienced compared to those who have been there many times, lost. They wouldn’t have lost if it weren’t for this wave or tsunami, but they did lose.

“Mr. Veto”

Well, let’s go back, there is a very important personal aspect, who will it be, but not only personal.

Forecasts are a bit different from scenarios. Because I’m really surprised when you present people with different pre-election scenarios, and then they take one: “Oh, so all analysts failed.” Listen, analysts won’t make predictions for you. These are scenarios, and you make predictions with additional information if you want.

Several scenarios arise, not just one. One scenario is when the acting administration, as Donald Trump said, will become “Mr. Veto,” that he will block everything. Well, he stated that.

– But will he?

– He won’t be able to. He will, but he won’t be able to. Why? Because I think he will have to negotiate some things with the Democrats. Then they simply won’t propose anything, won’t vote, won’t allocate any money, nothing.

“Possibilities to Start Impeachment Again”

They have all the possibilities now to start impeachment against the president again. But they know it won’t end effectively. And when Trump was forgiven twice already, his ratings only increased. Therefore, they will start with Heset, most likely, to see if it works on the defense minister…

– What’s the next step if it works with Heset?

– It’s unlikely that the same Republicans will support Trump’s impeachment, and they won’t have enough support. Heset might not reach the final stage either, but the Senate will now conduct a thorough investigation, unlike the two nominal votes with Trump when Democrats didn’t have a majority. Now there will be a very detailed investigation in the Senate, a trial that may not end with a verdict but can be very serious.

Investigation mechanisms, the so-called Subpoena, allow Congress to summon any executive branch leader. This starts with the president, since the president heads the government in America, and continues with the vice president, ministers, secretaries, and department heads. Previously, people came voluntarily, but Subpoena is a procedure that can end with criminal charges. Investigators will be involved, starting a completely different period.

Thus, Congress gains mechanisms of control and analysis of past actions. There have been various criticisms from Congress.

Secondly, they will vote on the budget. The NDAA hasn’t even been adopted yet. NDAA is the defense budget, with one and a half trillion dollars at stake. We’ll see if they can redistribute this money now, starting a serious discussion.

Thus, not only the House of Representatives, dealing with the budget or agenda, but the Senate as well, can block any new presidential appointee. This includes ambassadors, such as the ambassador to Ukraine, unfortunately. Likely, this issue will remain unresolved for a long time.

“Space Lasers Didn’t Work”

– Well, it seems to have been in such a state for quite some time.

– This is because the White House hasn’t submitted the nominee. Even if they do, it can still get blocked. Thus, one scenario is a fight potentially lasting until the presidential elections.

– Two years.

– Less than two years now, practically two years, let’s consider. They will start earlier with the election process, the primaries, and everything else. Other presidential elections, of course. Interestingly, no new people emerged during this campaign from either side to challenge the current ones politically for the presidency. However, new candidates might appear soon.

So, this scenario of chaos or constant struggle, continuous confrontation with Congress—now it’s Congress, veto on everything, bans on all matters—is very bad for us, for Ukraine.

– Many are already celebrating, yet you’re saying this.

– If it goes that way, it’s bad. But still, I think it would have happened if there was just a minimal advantage in the Senate. As it is now, if it continues and there might be 55-56 seats, assuming there are 54 now, they will realize within the party that they can’t go on with such baggage. So, I think voices will begin within the Republicans themselves… We will see it very quickly. This is reorganization in the White House, it could be the transfer of the finance committee from Trump, which his relative currently heads, to other people. We will see the appointments of Republicans themselves in Congress. Because when they appoint the head of a committee, there is a Republican deputy with whom all these issues are constantly discussed. We will see who they place there, preparing for the presidential elections.

The second scenario is more favorable, if Donald Trump personally understands that he has no chance in this war to remain president. He wanted to keep power for himself. For this, I think the chances are sharply decreasing, because now it’s unlikely that courts will act as before. The court is independent, fair, but it is not in a vacuum. American courts are in the political process, as are the media. And officials are already watching which way the wind blows. It’s not just like that, people want, as everywhere, to stay in office, to earn money. And in America, for example, even the sheriff is elected on a party basis.

This is not very good actually, because it’s almost like a doctor on a party basis. Well, here’s a sheriff from Democrats or Republicans. Moreover, a court clerk in a state is chosen by party affiliation. And these are ballots of three to four pages, where, if considering elections, there are seven to ten individuals, and then there are referendums on specific issues. So, I looked at some ballots, and there are indeed so many questions that we haven’t even discussed them.

A lot of progressives have now come among the Democrats. I don’t know what will come out of this because it needs analyzing, looking. Read what they say, it’s socialism with a communist tilt. Many have won on this, I’m not talking about them, I’m talking about the people who voted for this. People urgently want to lower taxes, people urgently want to address all these distortions (the wealthy earning more, which is indeed the case)…

– And you say they went against Trump, parallel to him.

– Trump is a representative of this group, Trump has let people profit from the Middle East crisis, the war, he allowed Exxon Mobil and large oil companies, which haven’t seen such profits for decades, to earn big. And people are paying more than $6 overall.

As I say, Musk relocated his major battery production facilities to Texas. And now he won’t have support from the governor and senator? How will he get many things? How will he solve environmental problems? A group of environmental supporters will come out against him, and do you know how much this costs? Musk won’t pay such amounts.

– Currently, he just joked that, supposedly, his “space lasers didn’t work.”

– I think they will now be in shock, counting how much money they have thrown into the air.

I don’t understand because throwing away 200 million could have been done simply, like they did in some states, technologically speaking, they essentially, frankly, were giving away buckwheat. If we take Musk, the same Internet connections, the same preferential aspects.

How will they look at everyone now? Di Vance supported Ramaswamy, who was a rising star, only just emerging or soaring into the sky. And he flew like plywood over Paris, this Ramaswamy.

But there are leftists as well. Bernie Sanders is a wonderful person, but Ocasio-Cortez, what she says and the fact that her ratings are growing now, you’ll see, the next polls will show she’s already somewhere second or third in the presidential ratings among Democrats. These are the leftists, called progressives. Well, in our system of coordinates, if we take Ukrainians, these are socialists. Did socialists advocate for war or for allocating funds for defense, or for supporting the Third World War globally, or anything else? No, I don’t know how they will act.

“Main Risks for Ukraine”

The main thing here is who will head the committees, who are the ideologists now with this new approach, how they will orient themselves. There are, of course, professional people, and we take it a priori that the Democrats are for us. Democrats are not for us, Democrats are against Trump. And the fact that Trump is with Putin causes irritation. By the way, this played a serious role. And Ukraine here again… The main thing is that our issue does not fall into impeachment, because there were constant connections: weapons supplies. And if the Democrats decide on impeachment, they will choose on what issue to impeach.

I really hope they don’t drag Ukraine into this story again, because good Democrats, essentially, dragged Ukraine into the conflict against Trump. That’s how it was. They’re good, but, you know, they think about themselves first and foremost. So, there will be scenarios further on. Whether it will be a war between Trump and Congress, this will not be a war between Republicans and Democrats, it will be a war between Trump and a group within the party… The first thing he will do is try to very quickly maintain control over his own, and then expand it.

And everything we are talking about now is still about January 3 and beyond next year, when the new Congress takes office. And right now, of course, there is little time for Congress, because they will work until Christmas. And that’s it. Therefore, Congress won’t manage to do anything grand right now. For example, the draft law on the extension for Ukrainians staying in America or the Adjustment Act regarding status changes. They won’t manage; they will move it to next year, and they might adopt it then.

But the White House will now do everything in these one and a half months to catch up or do those things…

— So this window can be used?

— Yes, it will definitely be used. The only problem is whether it’s sabotaged at the implementation level.

— Well, can time be dragged out?

— It can, just like with Ukraine, with weapons supplies, the logistics explanation was dragged out repeatedly for three weeks. Well, longer is not possible, because that’s prison for an official if he delays long after Congress’s funds and doesn’t execute. That’s prison.

– Let’s focus on the main risks regarding Ukraine.

– The main risk is the shift of focus, even attention shift, okay, the bigger risk now is that America, represented by Trump and the administration, is playing less of a mediator role and instead trying to pressure Ukraine to end the war on Russia’s terms. Well, in short.

On October 11, Donald Trump stated that Russia would like to make a deal to end the war, but for “some reason” the Ukrainian president does not want to. This statement came after a conversation with the Russian leader, after which the US and Russia concluded a “diesel deal.” Zelensky criticized this agreement, calling such a step a “weakness” of the US and a “gift” to Putin. After that, Trump stated he would like to see a new person as Ukraine’s president. Following these statements, American blogger and Trump supporter Laura Loomer, who visited Ukraine in July, said that instead of demanding elections in Ukraine, the international community should pressure Putin to end the war. Analysts from the American Institute for the Study of War (ISW) note that Putin took advantage of the phone conversation with Trump on October 9 to baselessly accuse Ukraine of a lack of progress in peace negotiations, despite the fact that Russia still does not wish to conduct constructive negotiations or make any concessions to end the war in Ukraine.

Will this change? It won’t change, because I don’t see a different approach there.

– So, pressure will be put on Zelensky, on Ukraine?

– Not on Zelensky. Pressure will be put on Ukraine. This is what we see publicly. And there are many other ways to put pressure. America is a big country, we have many connections with America. That’s the first thing. But if Congress doesn’t provide resources for this, or, for example, Congress doesn’t approve the allocation of resources for the continuation of the war in Iran, it means there can only be some operation now, which many predict. But what does it mean to predict? It may happen, it may not. There are a lot of factors…

The new Congress will not give money for the war in Iran, which means it won’t happen there, which means for us, two things will return: oil prices will decrease, not immediately, but quite quickly, because that’s the market. And if by January 1 there is no war in Iran, no American presence—well, the presence will be there, but I mean active attacks—then the issue will be resolved differently in the Strait of Hormuz and the Persian Gulf, and then prices will fall sharply. Right now they may jump if there is another attack, a strike. This is the first positive factor, conditionally, for Ukraine next spring.

The second factor is that the focus of attention may shift. We’re talking about the new Congress, but these are not new people, many remain. They have their legislative proposals, they will try to push them now because they were all blocked before. And put them forward again to pass because every congressman, congresswoman wants to show effective work.

Ukrainians participated more actively, I mean through relatives, through their American acquaintances. So the Ukrainian factor was present that way, especially this large group of Ukrainian forced migrants, some of whom, to be honest, didn’t come from Ukraine directly but were already in other countries, and almost fulfilled their American dream.)

“Trump’s Interest”

Next, we’ll see Trump’s own decision. I’m curious, I don’t know how he will act. Now he has a trip to Shenzhen with Xi Jinping, he will feel this attitude.

“Lame duck” is when it’s already before the elections at the end of the term. How to call this “duck” now, I don’t know, but it seems to me it has become “lame,” this is such a political conclusion of a “lame duck,” when now the US president is essentially a “lame duck.”

However, I wouldn’t underestimate his ability to block processes, because he heads the government, he is the president, and he has a lot of levers in his hands, he can practically block everything. And block arms supplies, some new contracts, and bilateral projects. Develop something without finances; as I said, some have already received, but many have not. Now the NDAA will be reviewed. We’ll see. So he might choose to trade.

He considers himself the best at making “deals” in the world. I would say “deals” – I still think it’s transactions in Ukrainian. And he will probably try, they will try to offer Congress a trade. You give for our purposes, and I don’t block some things, for example, prolonging TPS for Ukrainians. This is popular among voters.

– I think what worries everyone now is the aid to those Ukrainians who are here in Ukraine.

– We are concerned about aid, I understand. The reason I’m focusing on this is because Ukrainians in Ukraine are now more dependent not on Washington. We are in Kyiv, last night (the interview was recorded on November 5 – ed.) we saw how much we depend on Washington, and how much on the ability or inability of our managers to resolve crisis issues. Unfortunately, it’s not about Washington.

In short, the reason for our situation in Ukraine and Kyiv is Putin and Russia’s attacks, which see our institutional weakness. We saw today in Kyiv, we have no water and electricity not only because they constantly hit Kyiv’s energy ring, but also because the systems that were supposed to provide backup water pumping will arrive in Ukraine only in March. Why? Because they were fighting over whose funds it would be spent from. They fought too long. As a result, their political struggle, between the central government and Kyiv authorities, led to this catastrophe. It’s not the results of the elections.

– To the winter catastrophe, even before winter arrived.

– How can Americans help us in this situation? Well, obviously, by pressing in some way on Trump to change his approach in negotiations with Putin. Is it realistic or not? Pressure on Trump gave results.

In 2018, Trump returned a different person after his meeting in Helsinki with Putin.

US President Donald Trump and Russian leader Vladimir Putin shake hands during their meeting in Helsinki (Finland) on July 16, 2018.

There were also his images, really showed that he was very offended. As a result, he made three decisions: refused a meeting with Putin at the “G20,” in 2018, instructed the State Department, allowed Pompeo’s declaration that Crimea would never be recognized as Russian or annexed.

And thirdly, after that, we received anti-tank weapons “Javelins,” including after such things. So maybe he will behave like that. Trump’s interest is one – Trump.

By the way, another point, there will be deep bargaining, I think, because it’s an important matter. The bargaining is about Trump’s fate. They might question this within the party, making impeachment less likely. I mean, not impeachment in the House of Representatives, but a successful investigation in the Senate, which is less probable than pressuring him to step down due to health reasons. There is an article in the Constitution that has been raised, with medical professors saying that Trump is in such a state that he can’t govern the country. Honestly, it doesn’t appear that way externally, mainly due to his age. But to predict what will happen next, Congress might raise this issue very sharply. If he sees he’s losing the chance for his family to stay in power in the next elections, he might agree to it.

– Given all these scenarios and different possibilities, how interested would Trump be in trying to reach an agreement, hypothetically between Zelensky and Putin, regarding Ukraine’s fate and ending the war in Ukraine?

– If we put aside our current situation in winter, there’s no significant success for Russia on the ground. Otherwise, our negotiating positions are not so bad, I think they’re improving. This political change will positively affect Ukraine in any case, although it’s hard to say how positively. Clearly, this Congress will find more reasonable talks with the Europeans.

They will probably review some of the tariffs introduced against Europe as executive orders, which can be changed legislatively. For example, it’s currently complicated to import oil easily, like the Russian diesel tankers going to American ports, even though they aren’t wanted. But then there won’t be such a possibility, as a law prohibiting it, which exists, will be enforced by White House lawyers.

This will definitely be a different approach, as they will also worry about their future, realizing their boss is getting weaker. They don’t want to end up in prison. If negotiations took place in the spring, we would be in a much better situation than now. Russia and Putin understand this.

– You mean next spring?

– They want to pressure now while Trump is still in power, and he theoretically has the opportunity—not that he’s doing it—to not only refrain from providing weapons but also attempt to block European supplies and other actions. For example, I was surprised by the statement from Italy’s Prime Minister Meloni, accused of not providing an aid package from Italy because they’re waiting to see election results. What’s the connection between Italy’s national interests and the US election results?

But it means there is a connection. It means things will start improving now. It means that Europe will also see it, Europe will see that America can return to normalcy, and normalcy is Euro-Atlantic partnership, cooperation, joint actions, and it means a gradual return. By the way, Trump did not announce that he is leaving NATO, which could have happened now in this October timeframe because he was prohibited from doing so. Until October 1, the law forbade him from doing so. But in this interval before the elections, he had the opportunity to declare that the US is leaving NATO.

This would also have been a strong information blow, as he likes, but he didn’t do it. So, I think they will also now sit down and analyze how much they have lost. I do not anticipate a sharp change in approaches, but the goal of staying in power will not go away. And I tell you, they will reasonably count on the fact that the very Democrats, having gained such levers of power, will also lose ratings in the eyes of Americans in two years. And this has happened repeatedly. So we’ll see how it goes.

For now, it seems to me that such a scenario of complete blocking and war is definitely not needed by Trump. That is, I think he will try to make his deals, trade, exchange certain Congress decisions for his own decisions. And the first manifestation we will see immediately with Iran. That is, it will be seen. Well, and with the military budget, I think. It already seems to be formed, it’s hard for lobbyist groups to regroup, but we’ll see, there are certain positions where it will be clear what has happened…

Starlink in Ukraine

By the way, now they will definitely find out why suddenly Starlink was turned off in Ukraine.

– So, this is another aspect of the investigation?

– It will be very serious because StarShield or Starlink, let them come up with whatever they want, but there will be an investigation in Congress. And Musk will be walking around, like Zuckerberg did, remember, he attended it.

The Pentagon’s oversight body rejected a bipartisan request from US senators who asked to investigate the slowdown of StarShield (the military version of the Starlink service by the American company SpaceX) in Ukraine. This was mentioned in a letter from the US Department of Defense Inspector General, which was cited by several American media outlets and first reported by the Associated Press.

I think the consequence will be a more restrained situation regarding artificial intelligence or more cautious about its use. By the way, note that these elections showed there is an absolute consensus in the American political sphere and society that issues like elections cannot be digitized. And that artificial intelligence should not be allowed there.

– Are you also sending greetings to Ukrainian developers in this respect?

– Big greetings, especially to Mr. Fedorov, who said that cyber security threats are somewhat exaggerated. Nothing of the sort. Americans understand it’s not exaggerated. Right now, this story that Trump allowed the uncontrolled development of artificial intelligence in America, what he calls superintelligence, we understand why. To eliminate the difference between this advanced AI and the regular one. Now he will be accused of using it, and this will also be subject to investigation, that he consulted AI on what to do when deciding on the operation in Venezuela. So, all of this will come out if there is a war.

American media reported on the Pentagon’s use of AI during the operation in Venezuela, sparking a discussion about human control over military decisions. At the same time, there is no evidence that AI independently made decisions about conducting the operation or determining targets for impact. Defense Minister Pete Hegset insisted that American military should have the ability to use AI for any legitimate purposes without developer restrictions.

«Kamikaze Ambassador»

If there is a war, Ukraine will not be a priority. The best scenario for us, the ideal scenario, is if Ukraine becomes a unifying factor for Republicans and Democrats in Congress. This is possible; the Ukrainian caucus there is 99, and it could even increase. It might, because it’s popular. Why do they join the caucus? Because right now it is popular among the American people to support Ukraine. Therefore, the caucus could be large. And if Trump sees that he can win his points on this, well, it was obvious before, he acted differently, but if suddenly it happens, and suddenly it doesn’t because work needs to be done, explaining to him, to Congress and communicating, it is necessary to meet all these new people, show them the situation in Ukraine. If we think they know everything, nothing of the sort. They don’t know everything.

– Who should meet with them? There is no ambassador.

– No one, essentially, no one will meet with anyone. Or an ambassador…

– So, Ukraine now needs to do everything it can to urgently meet these new people…?

– Inform all these people among the Democrats.

– Appoint an ambassador.

– An ambassador, of course, should have been appointed yesterday. Certainly not to delay now, when the election results are clear, it needs to be resolved quickly.

To explain our position regarding the war to new Democrats, including those who will come to Congress, progressives, it will be necessary to speak with all of them, look at their programs. Besides the ambassador, the parliament leadership, parliamentarians who haven’t left yet could do this, since they canceled OSCE monitoring. Possibly, they should go. There’s no need to go to Washington and stay there. The people elected won’t be sitting in Washington now. They will be in their states, and they need to be found there. This is definitely targeted work.

– Representatives of Ukraine now need to look for ways to get acquainted…?

– With the new senators. People here evaluate only by numbers: Democrats, Republicans. For them, this ratio is enough to analyze the situation. For instance, for those working in America, Joni Ernst, who just left the Senate, is a National Guard veteran, she could still work, and she was the second candidate after Hegseth for the Secretary of Defense.

Trump didn’t go for it, although it was expected, the generals expected she would be appointed. She has now left the Senate, but I don’t know where she will be next. Klobuchar became the governor of Minnesota. She left, Klobuchar always strongly supported Ukraine. Now she is a governor, but frankly speaking, for us, the governor of Minnesota is a less critically important position than a Senate position regarding weapons and everything.

So, where Joni Ernst will be, where she will go, is important as she often helped us in matters where a senator’s personal position is crucial. For example, I arranged with her to have meetings in Congress, showing our films in Congress. It’s one thing to search around, but another when all the congressmen are watching. Congressmen will come there because their work is nearby. She resolved such issues, up to matters of weaponry and providing data from space intelligence, and so on. And the rocket engines, which we are not dealing with at all now, I don’t understand why. We still haven’t received American helicopters, and this was already in the works, it was close to a decision, and they are needed. There is a price, but we need to think about which ones, yet we don’t have American helicopters, essentially. Well, they are not there. Where are they?

At one time, we even tried flying the F-16s from our runways. It was just not publicized. And helicopters flew here when we almost had a contract. 2.5 years of work were thrown away. As a result, we have many unresolved issues in America that were practically impossible to push forward under the previous arrangements. It’s very difficult now, but there’s some opportunity for work that has emerged. And for an ambassador. I think it would be a kamikaze. It’s a kamikaze, a person who simply burns themselves out.

Because they walk a tightrope between Congress, the White House, today’s Pentagon, and intelligence, and make friends with some against others, you have to be very… I was in such a situation in a softer version. 45th President Trump.

– Would you go now?

– 45th President Trump – and it was very dangerous. It was necessary to constantly have contact with the entire Senate, with each senator. Because when these investigative commissions start fighting among themselves and so on.

Regarding the candidacy, so much has already been said…

– I wasn’t asking about that, I was asking if you would be interested, because you described it as a job for a kamikaze.

– If eight people refused, they refused for a reason. You understand, this period is not just before the next presidential elections, where there will still be a tough campaign, I think. It’s also now, when such an interim campaign has laid the groundwork for a possible clash.

An ambassador cannot solve these issues alone; there must be constant connection with President Zelensky, who by definition must be number one, but he also leads all the information work personally. He gets involved in it himself.

What three tasks, if a person who goes does this in support of the Ukrainian government, it would be great. To return America as a direct supplier of weapons. Because currently, it is not a direct supplier, but we have all the mechanisms for direct supply. They are created. That is, there are all legal grounds for this, let’s say, that’s one.

Second, to achieve the adoption of a whole group of laws to increase sanctions and political pressure on Russia. Because the laws that were adopted have completed their five-year term. According to American law, they are just taken into account now. They need to be accepted in this place. The main law was not even the Graham bill, but the one that passed in the House but was not supported by the Senate. The Ukraine Support Act – this is what we need, first.

We need the law against America’s adversaries, which highlighted and recorded the sanctions starting from Crimea, and everything further. This is possible. The ambassador can do this.

– You wanted to name three.

– And the third – I won’t say, because it will be implemented in the future. The third block of issues concerns strategy. These are very delicate issues. But they involve the struggle between Russia and Ukraine for Ukrainian identity. And America has certain levers for this. The Russians know this. The Americans are blocking them now, especially the American special services, for a long time. And here they are on our side, but to make it effective for us, for Ukraine, a lot of work needs to be done.

It’s a matter of trust, a matter of confidence in the unchangeability of Ukraine’s Euro-Atlantic European course, that we won’t start trading Ukraine now, any neutrality, reducing the number of troops, that sort of thing. They are looking at this now. And this is a serious opportunity for us. I don’t want to reveal it here because I’d like to keep something for the future.

I am ready to help in this regard anyone who goes and is interested in this. But I know that among the candidates that were considered, people were oriented in this. And the former Minister of Foreign Affairs. With all due respect, these are my colleagues in the diplomatic field. Someone from the president’s circle, like Svyrydenko, it was publicly known, Kubrakov, Umyerov. But if the decision is made – a professional diplomat nonetheless, then I would advise the president not to engage in this. Whether you go, whether you don’t. You work in public service, go. What’s the discussion here?

– Are you now pushing Zelensky towards dictatorship?

– No, this is public service. If you don’t want it, leave public service.

– What is Ukraine’s chance to implement at least part of these points? Bipartisan support wasn’t doubted, but how well will Ukraine be able to scale this support now?

– To start, we need to form our strategy, what we want.

Right now, it is formulated by weapons, sanctions, political isolation of Russia, and assistance in negotiations. I don’t know, if the mediator remains with the same approach, this is a road to nowhere. It will be exhausted by the end of the year. That’s it, just a few more attempts and it will end there. I don’t think Russia will agree to compromises now.

– So the negotiation track, regardless of the results of the U.S. midterm elections, comes to a logical conclusion?

– Yes, I believe it is coming to a conclusion.

Therefore, in the next period, the USA is unlikely to emerge as the States from this process. Donald Trump might emerge from this… But America will remain, the State Department and everything else. Europe will enter more, it must enter here. Europe must enter, and the Russians understand this. They understand that after January 1, they will only have the ability to block Ukraine. Or some scandals, they will try to involve Ukraine in scandals in America to make it unpopular in Congress. Here, it is necessary to work not only with the so-called political diaspora group. If you do not determine your strategy and tactics, you will not know what you need from the USA.

Therefore, anyone who works there, and work must be done in a team, must achieve the results that are set now. Here we have tactical goals, such as unlocking direct supplies from the USA. Guaranteeing satellite reconnaissance data that they will not disappear, and that Starlink will not be turned off for us. These are specific questions. Is it possible to ensure that Musk does not turn off Starlink himself? It is possible. Russia, of course, pressures Musk. But I don’t think we lack leverage, besides the much-publicized call there from Fedorov to Musk. Well, Zelensky called, and Musk did not want to talk.

I once looked for him, traveled to the spaceport to find him. He is a person with money and his own eccentricities. He has his own ideology, but we need to bring similar minds to him to communicate. We have such people. Musk really said that he considers our devices, space rockets, to be second in the world. His are the first, and these are the second. And where is this conversation? And we had the best engines, better than his.

There should not just be an ambassador or not an ambassador, but a person who knows Ukrainian politics and can call anyone, and Ukrainian politics is Akhmetov, Pinchuk.

You need to know all our leaders personally, communicate, our leaders of the Ministry of Defense, foreign intelligence, military intelligence. So that they know you. That is, the ambassador cannot just appear from the second row of diplomats.

A person must understand what a diplomatic service is, what it is to organize the work of an embassy, what it is in these conditions to arrive immediately, not like our previous Stefanishyna, who arrived and dealt with her arrangements instead of immediately focusing and going around.

Let me criticize her because she will now tell you that she had great success. What success? She met with the foreign affairs committee two months after her arrival or whenever she met them. But here you have to arrive and immediately go to Trump’s friend, and he lives in a completely different city, one or two real ones. And talk about what to do now with Donald, what are your suggestions.

For an ambassador with the position of ambassador, there is an opportunity. It would be better if it was a person with a spouse who can actively support him since there is a diplomatic line—Melania Trump.

By the way, we should also involve the president’s wife more actively now.

– You mean Olena Zelenska?

– Yes, Olena Zelenska. This is work, it’s not about assessing whether Trump is bad or good. Whether we like Melania or prefer Michelle Obama. An ambassador is not about likes; it’s about communicating with everyone.

And even if you don’t like it, you need to smile and achieve the things Ukraine needs. That’s all. Therefore, we can’t delay, and the decision is on the president’s desk, so I think he will make it rather quickly.

Since August 2026, Ukraine has not had its ambassador to the USA.

Source

 

Collage: Radio Liberty
Copyright © 2021 RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with permission from Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty

Автор