Blue wave and Ukrainian window

Blue wave and Ukrainian window

Victor Taran / Tyzhen

The Democrats took both houses of Congress, but they won not an ideological battle, but a struggle for the wallet of the average American. A window of opportunity is opening for Ukraine, which will start working in January, and it depends solely on us whether we manage to enter it.

Kansas hadn’t elected a Democrat to the U.S. Senate for almost a century, and this state became the symbol of the night of November 4th. Along with it, Democrats took Senate seats from Republicans in Iowa, Texas, Ohio, Maine, North and South Carolina. One of the biggest surprises was in Texas, where James Talarico defeated Trump’s candidate Ken Paxton. He became the first Democrat in 32 years to win statewide elections. According to leading American TV networks, Democrats will have at least 54 seats in the Senate, and will gain the largest majority in the House of Representatives in almost 20 years. This is in addition to five gubernatorial positions and up to 12 state legislative chambers, including the Texas House of Representatives, both chambers of Wisconsin, and the Pennsylvania Senate, which for the first time in 30 years shifted to the Democrats. Thus, the American press has every reason to talk about a blue wave, which this time truly covered the country from coast to coast.

However, the numbers themselves explain little, and it’s much more interesting to understand why this happened and what will happen next. On November 4, a panel discussion on the election results took place in Cambridge, which I joined online. The conclusions of its participants turned out to be much deeper than the usual scheme where one party simply defeats another. The main idea running through the entire conversation was that American politics is shifting from the competition of political brands to the struggle for who truly represents the interests of ordinary people.

After the Blue Wave: The Return of Grassroots Politics

The most interesting phenomenon of these elections, according to participants, was the return of power to grassroots movements. Volunteers, local activists, small civic organizations, youth, and local leaders mobilized voters in areas where party headquarters did not even plan to compete. Despite years of polarization, these local structures did not disappear but continued to work to protect citizens’ rights at the local level. And they ensured victories in districts that a year ago were considered hopeless for Democrats. Alongside Kansas, the participants in the discussion also mentioned Alabama, where shifts at the local level showed that even the most conservative states can no longer be considered guaranteed for Republicans.

An important role was played by lawyers and human rights organizations that protected voting rights and procedures, as well as the media that began to cover local issues more closely.

For us, this is an important lesson because it shows that American democracy relies not only on federal institutions in Washington but also on thousands of communities ready to defend their rights independently.

Economy vs. Politics: What Determined Americans’ Choice

The second key point concerned what exactly the Democrats presented to the voters. They had plenty of campaign topics: from the war with Iran to healthcare to political scandals and corruption surrounding Trump. But they focused on what Americans experience daily. The crisis of housing affordability/cost, rising prices for food, medicine, electricity, and fuel became the central messages of the campaign, proving to be much stronger than any ideology. Notably, even Vice President Vance explained the Republicans’ defeat primarily as a result of the war with Iran, which raised gas prices and heightened economic anxiety. Participants in the discussion warned that this victory also contains the main risk. If Democrats do not turn promises into tangible life improvements, new voters will leave them just as quickly as after 2022.

From Social Media to Doorsteps

As someone who previously worked as a political consultant, I can’t help but notice another aspect that upends many established notions. According to the Washington Post, Republicans spent more on advertising in competitive races each week since early September than Democrats. In the last week of the campaign, their expenses reached 305 million USD compared to 256 million USD by their opponents. Notably, Elon Musk made a record bet on these elections and lost. In Texas, Democrat Gina Hinojosa defeated incumbent Governor Greg Abbott, even though he spent five times more on TV ads, while Talarico won the Senate race, spending three times less on airtime ads than Paxton.

In other words, million-dollar budgets for advertising, particularly on social media, considered the main battleground in recent years, did not buy victory this time. They were outdone by traditional media, local TV, and newspapers, which voters trust more. But most importantly, the winning strategy was “direct communication,” where candidates and volunteers knock on doors, travel through small towns, and listen to people instead of speaking to them through algorithms.

This year, for the first time, the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee launched a separate program to work with rural voters. Local organizers noted that, for the first time in many years, they didn’t personally know half of the volunteers who went door-to-door. In over 1500 rural counties, Republicans received an average of 8 percentage points less than Trump did in 2024. An interesting lesson for those who claimed that the “electoral field” had permanently moved online. Traditional techniques remain more effective.

It’s particularly instructive how Democrats won in red states. Adam Hamilton’s victory in Kansas began preparing four years ago by focusing on those whom politicians had ignored for years. The pastor of the largest Methodist community in the US first toured the state with a listening tour. Then he presented a program addressing tariffs affecting farmers, prices, rural healthcare, and raising the minimum wage. In Seward County, where about half the voters are of Latino descent and many hadn’t previously voted at all, this strategy yielded noticeable results. The scoreboard numbers—Hamilton won with 53% against 45%.

Data Centers as the New Front of American Politics

An individual, and perhaps the most striking local theme of these elections, was data centers for artificial intelligence. On election day, communities in ten states voted on 41 local initiatives regarding them, 21 of which took place in Ohio. The result was almost unanimous: as of the morning of November 4, at least 33 initiatives to limit data centers were approved. The only victory for supporters of construction occurred in the small town of Harwood in North Dakota. People voted for full bans, temporary moratoriums, limits on electricity consumption, and mandatory voter approval for each new construction. In the town of Wells, Maine, over 80% of voters supported a 180-day moratorium, which also cancels previously issued permits. In Alhambra, California, the ban was also supported by more than 80%, and in Emporia, Kansas, the same state that elected a Democrat to the Senate for the first time in 94 years, voters voted for a construction ban. In Piqua, Ohio, the dispute over a data center project ended with voters recalling all three city commissioners involved in the decision. Over 70% voted for the recall, which then logically translated into support for the Democrats.

The reasons for such resistance are quite tangible. Data centers consume enormous amounts of electricity and water, often receive tax benefits, and shift network expansion costs onto regular consumers. Thus, people see them not as symbols of progress but as contributors to higher bills.

Democrats timely sensed this mood and in their advertisements directly accused opponents of closeness to large tech companies. Meanwhile, political funds from the artificial intelligence industry, despite considerable money, could not change the situation. This is a textbook example of how one specific local issue, visible from a voter’s window, turns into a national topic and changes election outcomes.

For me, as a former political strategist, this overturns the usual framework. I was taught that national elections don’t focus on local issues because they diffuse the main message. However, a campaign should adhere to a few large themes that are understandable nationwide. This time, it was precisely local issues — from reduced rural medical care to a data center raising electricity bills — that played in favor of the Democrats. Perhaps the explanation lies in the fact that governors and state legislators were elected alongside Congress, so the elections essentially turned into hundreds of local campaigns united by a common theme of life affordability. The big message about prices provided a framework, while local stories filled it with content that the voter recognized in their own life. In other words, a national theme wins when a person sees it on their street, and this lesson should be learned by everyone preparing for elections in Ukraine after the war.

Particular attention should be paid to a topic that just a few years ago seemed purely technological. Artificial intelligence and data centers are becoming a new source of political conflict. Voters see that they consume enormous amounts of electricity, strain local infrastructure, and raise the bills of ordinary households. Meanwhile, a few large corporations are reaping enormous profits. The seriousness of this issue is shown by the numbers. According to an NBC exit poll, 56% of voters named artificial intelligence and data centers as a decisive or important factor in their voting. Campaigns and outside groups spent $173 million on advertising about data centers, almost all of which was negative. People in communities are increasingly asking who truly benefits from technological progress, and participants in the discussion predict that by 2028, this question may become one of the main issues in American politics.

Thus, technological progress no longer guarantees political popularity, and this applies not only to the USA but to all countries competing for leadership in the field of artificial intelligence today.

The Future of the Republican Party

Participants in the discussion outlined two scenarios:

  • according to the first, the MAGA movement will retain control of the party even after a defeat;
  • according to the second, Republicans will gradually transform, seek new leaders, and increasingly rely on business elites and the heads of large corporations.

The answer to this question will determine how much American politics will depend on one person after Trump’s presidential term ends. The first signals are already here.

Which scenario prevails will show how much American politics will continue to be defined by his personal influence after Trump’s presidential term ends. The first signals are already here. One of them was the statement by Jim Jordan, one of Trump’s staunchest supporters in Congress, about his intention to lead the Republican minority in the House of Representatives. This may indicate that the party does not yet intend to abandon the MAGA course.

At the same time, Democrats face their own internal struggle. Victory sharpens the contradictions between the moderate establishment and the left wing, which advocates for large-scale social reforms. The way the party resolves this dilemma will determine whether it can maintain a broad coalition until the 2028 presidential election.

Participants in the discussion also offered an interesting conceptual view of American politics as a whole. In their opinion, the usual division into right and left increasingly fails to explain real processes, and it is much more accurate to look at the opposition between localism and globalism. On one side are local communities, the economic interests of specific regions, and the protection of their own resources, while on the other are international markets, global corporations, and the transnational economy. That is why voters with different ideological views sometimes support the same economic decisions, and parties should be assessed not by slogans but by the policies they actually implement.

The most concerning forecast of the discussion related to the next two months. The new Congress will only start working in January 2027, and until then, the current administration retains all its powers and control over both chambers. Discussion participants believe this period could be used for swift decisions in environmental policy, education, science, housing, and economic regulation, while pressure on universities like Harvard only highlights how vulnerable independent institutions can be.

The main unanswered question is whether American courts, universities, media, and civil organizations can restrain power when democratic norms are under pressure.

A Window of Opportunity for Ukraine: What Leverage the New Congress Will Have

The most important question for us now is what these elections mean for Ukraine. The shortest answer is that they open a window of opportunity but guarantee nothing. The President retains the right to veto, and the Democrats lack the two-thirds majority needed to overcome it.

The Democrats’ victory does not automatically mean an increase in military aid. However, Congress gains tools it did not have in the past two years. Relevant committees can inquire why the White House limited Ukraine’s access to Starshield, why there are delays in the delivery of Patriot, and under what conditions the easing of sanctions under the Graham Act was announced in October.

Even before the elections, Reuters wrote that the new composition of Congress could pave the way for the adoption of another package of military and financial aid to Ukraine, which may secure support from some Republicans.

An important tool of influence for the American parliament is control over the budget. Federal funds can only be spent with the appropriate appropriations approved by Congress. It is through the budget process that Democrats can influence the funding of defense programs, including joint projects with Ukraine, as well as the terms on which the administration will make agreements with Moscow.

Moreover, control over both chambers allows Democrats to initiate parliamentary investigations, demand documents, and summon officials for hearings. Consequently, the White House’s further decisions regarding Ukraine — from sanctions to satellite communication access — could become the subject of parliamentary oversight and public investigation.

For Kyiv, this means more opportunities to bring key issues into open discussion in Congress, which has traditionally been favorable to Ukraine.

However, it is worth realistically assessing the risks of the coming weeks. If the current administration indeed tries to maximize its time until January, decisions regarding Ukraine, including further easing of sanctions against Russia or new negotiation terms, could come under threat.

Therefore, Ukrainian diplomacy should already be working with both parties. Until January, real power remains in the hands of the Republicans, and after January, much will be decided through interaction between the White House and the Democratic Congress. Betting on one side during such a transition period would be a costly mistake.

At the same time, along with the old Congress, a generation of politicians who knew Ukraine personally is leaving, and this is probably the biggest hidden risk of these elections. Hundreds of new congressmen have come to Washington with the same questions about housing, fuel, and medicine prices. And for many of them, the war on the other side of Europe is still an abstraction.

Participants in the Cambridge discussion emphasized that American society needs to better understand the Ukrainian context and not perceive the war only through the lens of internal political struggle. It was also noted that Ukrainian military representatives, including those from the “Charter,” are already working with Congress, and this is the right approach because the voices of people from the front line carry more weight in Washington than any diplomatic notes. This is where Ukraine can and should act, as American politics is persuaded not by general appeals, but by specific arguments related to the interests of voters.

However, working with the new Congress only through the embassy is no longer sufficient. An ambassador can open doors, but it is primarily the voters from their districts who persuade congressmen. Therefore, Ukraine needs its own advocacy groups based on American communities.

The best example of such work was provided by Ukrainian Baptists. In the spring of 2024, when a $61 billion aid package for Ukraine was blocked for months in the House of Representatives, Ukrainian and American Baptists reached out through their church networks to Speaker Mike Johnson, who himself belongs to the Southern Baptist Convention. Well-known Ukrainian evangelical leader Pavlo Unguryan met with Johnson several times and brought a man to him whose wife and child died during a Russian attack on Odesa, and the head of the Southern Baptist Convention’s ethics commission, Brent Leatherwood, wrote to the speaker about over 400 churches destroyed by Russia. Eventually, Johnson brought the package to a vote against part of his own faction, and it passed with 311 votes to 112. This story shows that the strongest argument in Washington comes not from a foreign diplomat, but from a community with which the congressman shares faith, profession, or life experience.

What to do about this can be said quite specifically. First, it is worth establishing contacts with new members of key committees now, before January, because the first months of Congress will determine its priorities for the next two years. At the same time, advocacy networks should be created based on communities, from churches and the diaspora to veteran and reservist associations, universities, and professional associations that will speak to congressmen as neighbors, colleagues, or comrades, rather than as officials.

Next, it is necessary to speak to Americans in the language they just demonstrated in the elections. That is, to explain how Ukraine’s security is linked to energy prices, jobs in the defense industry of certain states, and the fact that Ukrainian drone and air defense technologies are already beneficial to America itself.

It is equally important to work not only with Washington but also with the same grassroots communities, universities, and local organizations that won these elections. After all, it is they who shape voter sentiment.

Finally, it is worth consistently exposing Russian financial influences and oligarchic networks in the US because the new Congress will have both the desire and the power to deal with them.

Americans in this election made it clear that what interests them most is their own lives, and there is nothing surprising or offensive about this for us. The Democrats did not win a guarantee of power until 2028, but merely a chance to prove that they can make people’s lives better. Similarly, Ukraine received not ready-made assistance, but a chance to convince the new Congress that our security is part of American prosperity. Kansas, which voted the same way for a hundred years, decided differently this time, and this is the best reminder that nothing is definitive in politics. A window has opened, and now it all depends on how quickly and professionally we take advantage of it.

Source

 

Collage: Telegraf

Автор