On the eve of the summit of the leaders of the United States, Russia, and China in Shenzhen, a cardboard installation featuring images of Trump, Putin, and Xi Jinping was placed in Yalta against the backdrop of the monument celebrating Franklin Roosevelt, Winston Churchill, and Joseph Stalin that had been installed during the occupation. The very material it was made from became the best characteristic of the event that took place in China.
Even before the summit of the leaders of the USA, Russia, and China took place, it started being called historic—the participants continued to boast about the “historicity” of the event even after they left Shenzhen. Indeed, the leaders of the USA, Russia, and China had never met in a trio—although both Putin and Trump always gravitated toward such a format. However, this summit would have truly been historic if its participants had the ability to offer the world certain outlines of a new system of international security or at least their trilateral cooperation and the possibility to bring these plans to life. But nothing similar happened—and it couldn’t have.
In Yalta in February 1945, everything was entirely different. The allies were already winning the war and could recall how different their countries and interests actually were. They drew lines on the map but were also building an entirely new world that didn’t exist before World War II—after which the United States transformed into the true leader of the free world and an economic dominant. That’s why all post-war US presidents—starting, of course, with the wartime leader Franklin Roosevelt—appear in our imagination as real political giants, and we remember most of them like rock stars, whereas Roosevelt’s predecessors as US President are recalled only in historical monographs. And it was after World War II that the Soviet Union transformed from a poor Bolshevik dictatorship into a Russian empire with influence on almost all continents—Stalin donned the epaulettes of a Generalissimo, rejected the communist anthem “Internationale,” and even the term “Bolshevik” in the name of the ruling party. This Yalta order—in terms of international law and new world institutions—truly outlasted both Stalin and the Soviet Union itself.
The participants of the summit in Shenzhen are building no new international order. Rather, they dream of an old order. In Putin’s fantasies, the new order is a return to Russian achievements of the Yalta era. The president of a country that is stuck in eastern Ukraine for almost five years now demands recognition of Russia’s right to a “sphere of influence” from Ljubljana to Ashgabat. His American counterpart harbors ambitions reminiscent of America before World War II. Trump genuinely wishes to be feared and obeyed by all, while being obligated to no one.
The only thing that doesn’t suit the participants of the Shenzhen meeting about the Yalta system is what was the main point of consensus among its participants. Not just the boundaries of spheres of influence, but international institutions—because by 1945, it was already clear that some, albeit imperfect, mechanisms of arbitration and interaction needed to be found to prevent a new war. However, the declaration signed in Shenzhen dedicates two points to the inefficiency of international organizations—and there’s no need to remind how much the International Criminal Court irks Trump and Putin.
The paradox of the Shenzhen meeting is that even such a cardboard version suited Putin just fine. It was the very group photo that allowed the Russian president to claim to be one of the leaders of the modern world alongside the heads of the USA and China—making the comparison with Yalta one of the most successful finds of recent Russian propaganda.
And yes—another license. A license to kill. A license to kill Ukrainians. Because in Putin’s mind, the very fact of “recognition” and negotiations at the table of three gives him the chance to feel his impunity, and most importantly—the right of a leader to act at his discretion and consider himself an arbiter of the fate of countries and people.
And that is why for every missile, for every drone that explodes today in Ukrainian cities, responsibility lies not only with Putin but also with the other two participants of the Shenzhen summit, who treated the Russian president as a partner, not as a criminal.
They became not just participants of the summit, but accomplices to Putin.
Illustration generated by AI
