Is it possible to restore the Kerch Bridge?

BBC News Ukraine

The Kerch Bridge seems to have suffered the most serious damage since the beginning of the full-scale war. Experts say that Russia is unlikely to restore it before the end of the war — and it might even be easier to build a new one.

Meanwhile, Ukraine’s Defense Minister Yevhen Khmara briefly commented to Radio Liberty on the destruction of the road section of the bridge over the Kerch Strait, which connects Russia with occupied Crimea, ahead of the meeting of Ukraine’s allied defense ministers in the “Ramstein” format.

“We’re just getting started,” Khmara replied when asked for a comment by Radio Liberty.

Can Moscow compensate for the loss of the crossing with other routes, and is occupied Crimea facing a transport blockade?

What is known about the damage

On the night of November 17, the Kerch Bridge was attacked again. According to monitoring channels, one of the arches collapsed and fell into the Kerch Strait.

The General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine stated that the road section of the bridge was completely disabled, and the railway also suffered damage. Volodymyr Zelensky reported that the operation had been prepared for several weeks and was coordinated by the SBU and the General Staff.

Initially, the traffic on the bridge was completely stopped. Later, rail traffic was restored on one track, while repairs continue on the other. The road section remains closed.

Russian Deputy Prime Minister Marat Khusnullin reported that a government commission discussed alternative routes for delivering goods to Crimea, assessed the damage, and began restoration work.

Officially, the Russian Investigative Committee announced “damage to the structure” due to a drone attack. Ukraine, along with independent experts, speaks of a strike not only by drones but also missiles, particularly “Flamingo.”

According to reports from monitoring Telegram channels, one of the arches of the Kerch Bridge has been destroyed. Photo: Exilenova+
What experts say

“This is consistent with heavy FP-5 ‘Flamingo’ cruise missiles, which are produced in Ukraine, possibly modified for remote control to increase accuracy in the final flight phase and ensure impact on the supporting structures of the Kerch Bridge,” Justin Bronk from the Royal United Services Institute told the BBC.

After the first strike on the bridge on Monday, November 16, the steel arch of the road bridge suffered structural damage, noted Emil Kastehelmi, co-founder and analyst of the OSINT project Black Bird Group, on X.

In his assessment, the combined strike on Tuesday led to “complete collapse.”

The damage to the main span of the bridge can be classified as “catastrophic,” Professor of Structural Engineering at Australia’s Monash University Colin Caprani told the BBC.

“You don’t need an engineering degree to understand what this means! It is completely destroyed,” explained the specialist.

In this situation, repairing the bridge will be more complicated than building it from scratch due to numerous debris underwater and potential damage to the supports and foundation.

Kapran does not rule out that some surviving structures may need to be completely dismantled before repairs can begin. The restoration of the bridge will take many months.

“It’s very difficult to imagine how such reconstruction would be possible in a location that is easily subjected to further attacks while hostilities continue,” concludes the professor.

Emil Kastehelmi of Black Bird Group also believes that the road bridge will not be restored before the end of the war.

“Ukraine has won – with both specific and symbolic consequences,” he writes.

However, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov promised that the Kerch Bridge will be restored.

“The sequence and timeline of the restoration work will be determined. There is actually no doubt that the bridge will be restored and it will be even better than before,” he said.

Meanwhile, the company Ambrey, which specializes in shipping security, reported to Financial Times that the automobile arch fell into the Kerch-Yenikalsky channel.

This is the deepest shipping route between the Azov and Black Seas. Due to the bridge debris, commercial vessels cannot use it, further harming the export of grain, fuel, and fertilizers.

Before the arch collapse, writes founder of “SovEcon,” agri-industry specialist Andrey Sizov, the supply of grain from Russia could have been quickly restored in case of a maritime truce.

“Now no longer,” he states, as the Kerch-Yenikalsky channel must first be cleared of debris.

“The channel passes under the arched part of the bridge and is the only shipping path between the Azov and Black Seas,” explains Sizov. According to his company’s estimates, about 25% of Russian grain exports usually go through the Azov Sea. Shipping in the region was suspended in July this year amid attacks.

In his opinion, clearing the channel could take several weeks or months.

Does Crimea face a transport blockade?

Analysis by BBC military observer Ilya Abishev

The Kerch Bridge over the Kerch Strait has already survived two major attacks, which caused serious damage to the vehicle spans.

This occurred on October 8, 2022, and July 17, 2023.

However, the current damage appears more extensive.

This time, large arched structures are damaged.

After the attack on November 16, vehicle traffic on the bridge was restricted. Later, Russian Deputy Prime Minister Marat Khusnullin reported that it was restored in a reverse mode.

A repeat attack during the night of November 17 proved even more powerful.

It used not only drones but also missiles – specifically the FP-5 “Flamingo.”

Explosions were heard again in the bridge area – in the same part of it that had been hit the day before.

In the video footage that appeared on Tuesday morning, one of the vehicle arches is missing, and a section of the roadway is in the water. The parallel arch structure of the railway section remains standing but may also be damaged.

According to reports from Western and Ukrainian media, the entire massive vehicle arch, about 227 meters long, has collapsed and fallen into the strait. This is evidently a critical damage to the crossing. The arch is not just a decorative element of the bridge. It plays a role in load distribution and supports the span structure, ensuring the stability of the entire system.

It is too early to speak of a complete blockade of Crimea. However, the risk of a serious transport and logistics crisis has significantly increased.

The destruction of the Kerch Bridge’s arch structure limits the connection with Russia—at least until the crossing is restored.

Meanwhile, Crimea is not completely cut off from the world.

Firstly, there remains a land corridor through the occupied areas of Zaporizhzhia and Kherson regions. However, Ukraine systematically strikes at transport routes in northern Crimea, bridges, and other crossings in the Chongar area. This has already created problems with fuel and other cargo deliveries, including military supplies.

Secondly, there is a ferry crossing over the Kerch Strait.

It can partially compensate for the loss of the bridge, but its capabilities are very limited. Moreover, the crossing itself is also vulnerable to Ukrainian strikes.

Thirdly, Russia can supply goods to occupied Crimea by sea. But this route is also fraught with risks, as many Ukrainian naval and aerial drones operate in the waters.

Additionally, the debris of the Kerch Bridge, especially its huge arch, could block the shipping channel. This complicates the passage of large vessels and creates additional problems for the Sea of Azov ports, which are currently occupied by the Russians, Mariupol and Berdiansk.

The Kerch Bridge – a legitimate military target

Kyiv has repeatedly stated that it considers the Kerch Bridge a legitimate military target, as Russia uses it to supply its troops.

In his announcement about the operation, Volodymyr Zelensky also emphasized that the strike on the bridge was a response to Russian attacks on Ukrainian civilian infrastructure.

“Russia strikes our infrastructure daily, including bridges in Zaporizhzhia, Dnipro, Kyiv, and the Odesa region. We restore our infrastructure. But we also remind Russia that war will always return to where it started,” the president said.

This is not the first major attack on the Kerch Bridge since the start of Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine.

In October 2022, a truck with explosives was detonated on the bridge, damaging several spans.

In the summer of 2023, the bridge was attacked by naval drones, destroying one of the vehicle spans.

In the summer of 2025, the Armed Forces of Ukraine conducted another operation, placing explosives under the bridge’s supports. At that time, Russian authorities claimed that the structure was undamaged.

The Security Service of Ukraine stated that “since the beginning of the full-scale invasion of the Russian Federation, the Kerch Bridge has been the target of four successful special operations by the SSU,” evidently considering the latest attack.

“During this time, we found new solutions, changed approaches and means of attack: from a truck with explosives and Sea Baby maritime drones to underwater mining and long-range air strikes,” stated the SBU message.

And every time, our employees inflicted critical damage to the bridge, which the Russians considered unreachable and even “eternal.”

Source

 

Collage on cover: social networks/BBC

Автор